Key Takeaways
1. Waymo celebrates its ten millionth paid autonomous ride, while Tesla’s robotaxi service is set to launch in June.
2. Tesla’s pilot program will start with ten Model Y vehicles operating only in the safest areas of Austin, using geofencing similar to Waymo’s approach.
3. Musk claims Tesla’s AI can adapt quickly to driving situations, but they will still use pre-mapping and geofencing.
4. Tesla’s Model Y robotaxis will have operators ready to intervene, and training for local first responders has begun.
5. There is a debate on safety between Tesla’s cost-saving approach and Waymo’s use of LiDAR and extra sensors for enhanced safety.
While Waymo is proud to announce that it has completed its ten millionth paid autonomous ride, Tesla’s CEO, Elon Musk, has stated that their own robotaxi service, set to launch in June, will be very similar.
Pilot Program Details
Musk mentioned that the initial rollout will start small, featuring around ten Model Y vehicles. These will only operate in the “safest” parts of Austin, where the pilot will take place. This approach seems to echo the geofencing methods used by Waymo, even if Musk has often criticized their strategy.
AI and Safety Measures
During the last earnings call, Musk promoted Tesla’s “generalized” AI system, which he claims can quickly adapt to different driving situations without needing detailed maps like other companies. However, it appears that Tesla will indeed undertake pre-mapping and geofencing.
“We are actually going to deploy not to the full Austin area, but just the safest parts,” revealed Musk. “So we will geofence it… It’s not going to take intersections unless we are really confident it will do well,” he added.
Safety Protocols
Even though the Model Y robotaxis will operate without a driver, there will be operators ready to step in if necessary, similar to Waymo’s setup. Tesla has already begun training Austin first responders and police on how to handle its driverless robotaxis, suggesting that the platform will initially follow a traditional model like others in the industry.
The key selling point is that Tesla will use standard Model Y vehicles, which are 20%-25% cheaper per unit than the customized Waymo vehicles equipped with LiDAR and additional sensors, according to Musk.
Different Perspectives on Safety
However, John Krafcik, Waymo’s former CEO, disagrees, arguing that the cost savings from using Tesla’s vehicles aren’t worth the potential safety risks. He contends that the LiDAR and extra sensors have a “trivial cost-per-mile impact over the useful life of a robotaxi while also providing massive quantifiable safety benefits.”
In the end, it’s unclear whose approach will prove more successful in the long run, as Tesla prepares to kick off its robotaxi venture next month in Austin with a limited fleet and within a geofenced area.
Source:
Link