Key Takeaways
1. TCL cannot label its displays as QLED due to minimal use of the technology, leading to misleading advertising.
2. A German court ruled against TCL after a lawsuit from Samsung, deeming their QLED marketing unfair and misleading.
3. The court’s decision focused on TCL’s inadequate use of quantum dots, which failed to deliver the expected color improvements associated with QLED TVs.
4. This is not TCL’s first legal issue in Germany; they previously faced a ruling over their “NXT FRAME” branding infringing on Samsung’s trademark.
5. TCL is currently facing similar class-action lawsuits in California and New York, while fellow manufacturer Hisense is also dealing with legal challenges in the U.S. regarding QLED marketing.
The Chinese television manufacturer TCL, which ranks among the largest in the world, is unable to label its displays as QLED. This is mainly because it only uses the technology minimally in TVs that are marketed as such, aiming to cut costs, which does not provide any real advantages in brightness or color quality for consumers.
Legal Setback for TCL
In a setback for TCL, a court in Germany has determined that the company’s use of the QLED label is misleading. As a result, they have been ordered to stop certain advertising efforts immediately. This decision comes after a lawsuit from Samsung Electronics, where the Munich 1st District Court concluded that TCL’s QLED870 series and other models breached the German Unfair Competition Prevention Act.
Quantum Dot Controversy
The heart of the court’s decision revolves around the implementation of quantum dots (QD). While the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) defines QLED TVs as those using a specific QD film to boost color between the backlight and panel, the court found that TCL’s technology was inadequate. By using only a small quantity of quantum dots in the diffuser, these TVs did not provide the noticeable color improvements that consumers associated with the QLED branding. Therefore, the court ruled this marketing strategy as an unfair trade practice.
Previous Legal Issues
This isn’t the first time TCL has faced legal troubles in this region; the company previously lost a case regarding its “NXT FRAME” branding, which was deemed to infringe on Samsung’s “Frame” trademark. The recent injunction in Germany effectively prevents TCL from selling or advertising these particular models under the QLED name in the country.
Currently, TCL is also confronting similar class-action lawsuits in California and New York. Additionally, fellow Chinese manufacturer Hisense, which is the largest TV maker in the world, is facing its own legal challenges in the U.S. concerning its QLED marketing claims.
Source:
Link










