Category: Computers

Key Takeaways

1. Microsoft introduced Majorana 1, claiming it to be the first topological quantum bit (qubit) using a new architecture.
2. Researchers are skeptical of Microsoft’s claims due to the difficulty in capturing Majorana particles and concerns over a lack of supporting details in their publication.
3. Critics highlight that previous issues, such as a retracted 2018 paper, have led to doubts about Microsoft’s current assertions.
4. Some scientists suspect the announcement may be exaggerated or even fraudulent, as it lacks evidence from peer-reviewed research.
5. Microsoft plans to present more definitive research on their findings at the Global Physics Summit in March 2024.

Scientists appear skeptical of Microsoft’s ambitious statements regarding Quantum computing. The tech giant from Redmond recently introduced Majorana 1, a quantum processor designed with a “Topological Core architecture,” making the strong assertion that it represents the first topological quantum bit (qubit).

Theoretical Potential

Microsoft claims this technology could potentially support future advancements with as many as a million qubits. However, researchers are not so sure. Majorana particles have proven to be quite difficult to capture, with their existence first being proposed in 1937.

Scientific Community’s Concerns

The assertion that Microsoft has not only detected the particle but also integrated it into a chip has raised eyebrows in the scientific community. Critics argue that the company’s publication on the subject lacks crucial details and, due to a prior incident where a 2018 paper was retracted, doubts persist about their current claims.

“This is a piece of alleged technology that is based on basic physics that has not been established. So this is a pretty big problem,” said Sergey Frolov, a physics and astronomy professor at the University of Pittsburgh, in a conversation with The Register.

Doubts About the Announcement

Frolov noted that the announcement was so “dramatic” that it led to suspicions of it possibly being “a fraudulent project.” Winfried Hensinger, a physicist from the University of Sussex, expressed in Physics Magazine that there is no evidence backing “topological qubits” in Microsoft’s recent paper.

He pointed out that Microsoft’s press release suggests they have discovered the particle when, in fact, the paper does not provide any supporting evidence.

“You shouldn’t make claims that are not supported by a peer-reviewed publication,” Hensinger remarked.

Upcoming Presentations

Chetan Nayak, who leads the Azure Quantum team at Microsoft, told Physics Magazine that the evidence for the qubit particle was gathered during the submission in March 2024. He mentioned that he plans to share more definitive research at the Global Physics Summit in California, set for March 16.

In a statement to The Register, a representative from Microsoft said, “There is a lot of science to explain when it comes to quantum computing, and in the coming weeks and months, we look forward to sharing our results along with additional data behind the science that is turning our 20 plus year vision for quantum computing into a tangible reality.”

Source:
Link