Key Takeaways
1. Personal Disappointments: Gamers express their letdowns with franchises like Halo 5: Guardians and Borderlands 3 due to poor storytelling, despite good gameplay.
2. Major Letdowns: Titles such as Kerbal Space Program 2 and Payday 3 are seen as significant declines in quality, with the community largely agreeing on these disappointments.
3. Industry Concerns: The discussion reflects broader issues within the gaming industry, including live service models, aggressive monetization, and a lack of creative vision.
4. Trust Erosion: A single misstep in a beloved series can drastically change gamers’ expectations and trust in developers, even for legacy companies like EA and BioWare.
5. Cautionary Tales: Games that improved post-launch, like Cyberpunk 2077, are still viewed skeptically, as the community tends to remember past failures.
A Reddit discussion titled “Which entry to a game series was so bad it spoiled the name of its whole legacy and faith in the developers?” is making headlines, amassing over 900 comments in just twelve hours. When gamers experience a fantastic game, they tend to create high hopes for future installments. If those hopes are dashed, it can dramatically alter their perception of the entire series.
Personal Disappointments
User u/Ltaustin117 pointed out Halo 5: Guardians and Borderlands 3 as his personal letdowns. Both of these franchises are viewed as iconic in gaming, so the anticipation for their sequels was understandably significant. While the gameplay has its merits, he emphasizes that the poor storytelling alone was enough to shake his confidence in the series.
Major Letdowns
Redditor u/GarlicThread also highlighted Kerbal Space Program 2 and Payday 3, calling them huge disappointments. Both of these games are seen as steps backward in terms of technical performance and content when compared to their earlier versions, and it seems the community is in agreement. This particular comment has garnered the most upvotes so far. Other common mentions of disappointments include:
The ongoing Reddit conversation transcends individual failures, focusing on what many perceive as deeper concerns within the gaming industry, such as live service models, aggressive monetization, and a lack of creative vision. Gamers used to trust legacy developers like EA, Blizzard, and BioWare, but even one misstep in a cherished series can be a turning point, drastically altering expectations for upcoming releases. Notably, even games that experienced significant improvements after troubled launches, like Cyberpunk 2077 or Star Wars: Battlefront II, are still viewed by many as cautionary tales. As one commenter remarked: “The community doesn’t forget.”
Join the Conversation
If you have opinions on this subject or want to share your own experiences with disappointing sequels, feel free to chime in the comments.
Source:
Link




