Key Takeaways
1. Different tastes in video games lead to passionate defenses of titles often deemed “bad.”
2. Resident Evil 6 is a prime example, appreciated by fans for its unique qualities despite criticism.
3. Other games like Mass Effect: Andromeda, Fallout 76, Dragon Age 2, and Dark Souls 2 also have dedicated supporters despite their flaws.
4. The Reddit thread showcases a positive atmosphere, with users feeling relieved to find others who share their opinions.
5. Nostalgia and personal experiences play a significant role in how players defend their favorite games, regardless of critical reception.
Tastes can differ greatly, and video games are no different. A recent discussion on Reddit named “What’s a game that most people consider ‘bad’ but you will defend and be a hill you would die on?” highlights this fact. Within just 18 hours, the thread received over 1,700 comments and ignited a vibrant discussion about games that are often viewed as poor yet are still cherished by many.
The Case for Resident Evil 6
The thread’s creator, u/Cheesecake1901yum, began by standing up for Resident Evil 6. This title is frequently labeled as the outlier in the series due to its focus on action over horror, a disjointed narrative, and inconsistent level design, earning it a modest 5.4 User Score on Metacritic. Nevertheless, it has a loyal fanbase that appreciates its unique qualities.
Other Games Worth Defending
Several familiar titles popped up in the discussion. Mass Effect: Andromeda faced backlash for its bugs and underdeveloped characters, but some gamers highlight its engaging combat and world-building. Fallout 76 had a rocky start but eventually attracted fans with its immersive atmosphere. Dragon Age 2 is often seen as polarizing; it’s criticized for repetitive settings yet lauded for its compelling characters and emotional depth. Dark Souls 2, frequently considered lesser than its predecessor, still shines with features like powerstancing and PvP that many players enjoy.
A Positive Outlook
The overall vibe of the thread is surprisingly upbeat. Many users feel relieved to discover others share their opinions, often starting comments with phrases like “I thought I was the only one” or “Finally someone said it!” There’s also a sense of humor, with statements like “I know it’s bad, but I love it.” The reasons behind the affection for these so-called bad games are varied: personal preferences play a crucial role, but positive memories also contribute significantly. Games played during joyful moments in life often hold nostalgic value, encouraging players to “die on that hill” for their favorites.
Source:
Link


