Tag: Patent Infringement

  • Qualcomm Sues Transsion, Maker of Infinix, Tecno, and itel

    Qualcomm Sues Transsion, Maker of Infinix, Tecno, and itel

    In an unexpected development, Qualcomm has initiated legal action against Transsion, the fourth-largest smartphone maker globally, citing alleged infringements on four of its patents.

    According to IP Fray on LinkedIn, the lawsuit concerns four unspecified non-standard essential patents owned by Qualcomm. What makes this situation particularly unique is that Transsion does not incorporate Qualcomm’s Snapdragon processors in any of its current smartphone models.

    A Different Approach

    Qualcomm usually uses its significant influence in the mobile chip industry to negotiate licensing agreements when its patents are breached. However, this approach isn’t applicable to Transsion, which primarily uses processors from MediaTek and Unisoc, as reported by WinFuture.

    Despite not utilizing Qualcomm’s chips, Transsion boasts popular brands such as Tecno, Itel, and Infinix. These brands focus on the budget and mid-range smartphone markets, a strategy that has led Transsion to become the fourth-largest smartphone manufacturer globally, following Samsung, Apple, and Xiaomi, according to Statista.

    Potential Impact

    This rapid growth seems to have attracted Qualcomm’s scrutiny, resulting in this lawsuit over unspecified “non-standard essential patents.” The lawsuit’s outcome is still uncertain, but it could compel Transsion to pay licensing fees, which might significantly affect their already thin profit margins on budget devices.

    Qualcomm’s new lawsuit comes amid pressure from other major tech companies. The Financial Times reports that Philips has also sued Transsion, while Nokia is seeking licensing fees for its patented technologies used in Transsion’s phones.

    Ongoing Developments

    Interestingly, a Transsion spokesperson stated in the Financial Times report that the company has signed a “5G standard patent license agreement” with Qualcomm and asserts that it is meeting its obligations under that agreement. This raises questions about why Qualcomm chose to file a lawsuit if that is indeed the case.

    The resolution of this legal battle and its impact on Transsion remains uncertain. We will continue to provide updates as new information becomes available.


    Qualcomm Sues Transsion, Maker of Infinix, Tecno, and itel
  • Jury Fines Microsoft $242 Million for Cortana Patent Infringement

    Jury Fines Microsoft $242 Million for Cortana Patent Infringement

    A US jury has imposed a substantial fine of $242 million (approximately ¥1.75 billion) on Microsoft for infringing on a patent. The ruling, delivered in Delaware on May 10, resulted from a lawsuit brought by IPA Technologies in 2018.

    Microsoft to Challenge Jury's Decision

    Microsoft intends to challenge the jury's decision, which alleged that Microsoft's Cortana voice assistant violated IPA's patent related to voice recognition technology in computer communication software. Initially, the lawsuit encompassed multiple IPA patents, but eventually focused on a specific one. Microsoft contended that they did not breach the patent and that the patent itself was invalid.

    Background and Acquisition of Patents

    IPA Technologies, a subsidiary of Wi-LAN, obtained the disputed patent from SRI International's Siri Company. Subsequently, Apple acquired Siri Company and its technology in 2010, incorporating it into their Siri voice assistant.

    Microsoft's Response and Future Actions

    Microsoft has expressed its intention to appeal the verdict, stating, "We firmly believe we did not infringe." IPA and Wi-LAN have yet to provide any public statements regarding the matter.

    IPA Technologies has a history of legal action in this domain, having previously sued Google and Amazon over comparable patents. Amazon effectively defended itself in 2021, whereas the case involving Google remains ongoing.