Key Takeaways
1. The Asus TUF A15 features an RTX 4060 GPU, while the XMG Neo 15 is equipped with a more powerful RTX 3080 Ti, which has 16 GB of VRAM compared to the RTX 4060’s 8 GB.
2. The RTX 3080 Ti offers superior performance, especially at 1440p, with benchmark scores indicating around a 15% performance advantage over the RTX 4060.
3. The XMG Neo 15 has a higher specification overall, including a Ryzen 9 6900HX processor, 64 GB of RAM, and a 1440p 240 Hz display, but it is pre-owned.
4. Concerns about the condition of older hardware were raised, highlighting the importance of checking for wear and tear and considering maintenance like thermal repasting.
5. The RTX 4060 includes newer features like DLSS 3 Frame Generation, but its limitations in VRAM and power compared to the RTX 3080 Ti are significant factors in the discussion.
In a recent post on Reddit by user u/F1vr, members of the r/GamingLaptops community discussed a hardware exchange situation. The question at hand was whether to trade a current-generation Asus TUF A15 laptop that has an RTX 4060 for a pre-owned XMG Neo 15 (M22) equipped with an RTX 3080 Ti which operates at 175 W.
Laptop Specifications
The TUF A15 was acquired in December 2024 and is powered by a Ryzen 9 8845HS processor, an RTX 4060 GPU, 32 GB of DDR5 RAM, a 1080p 144 Hz screen, and offers 2 TB of SSD storage. The Neo 15 in question has a Ryzen 9 6900HX, an RTX 3080 Ti (175 W), 64 GB of DDR5 RAM, a 1440p 240 Hz display, and a 1 TB SSD, along with an external water-cooling unit. The seller is asking for €1,100 (about USD 1,200), with the original poster mentioning that the TUF could fetch a higher selling price.
Community Insights
Comments were largely centered around performance and overall value. Many users highlighted the 16 GB of VRAM in the RTX 3080 Ti, which is twice that of the RTX 4060, and emphasized its superior rasterization performance at 1440p. Others pointed out that the 175 W thermal design power (TDP) of the 3080 Ti provides it with an edge in laptops that do not have thermal constraints.
Benchmark Comparisons
Benchmarking data backs up these observations. Internal tests show that the RTX 3080 Ti Laptop GPU has an average 3DMark Time Spy Graphics score of 11,802, with some peaks reaching 13,808. In contrast, the RTX 4060 Laptop GPU averages at 10,250, with a maximum score of 11,738. This indicates a performance gap of around 15% favoring the 3080 Ti in this type of synthetic rasterization test.
Condition Considerations
Beyond performance metrics, the condition of the hardware was also a significant topic. Some users raised concerns about wear and tear on older models, suggesting that a complete thermal repaste and a motherboard inspection should be done before any swap, particularly for devices that might have been under heavy load for long times.
In addition to the performance and condition aspects, the RTX 4060 introduces newer architecture and features like DLSS 3 Frame Generation. However, as the discussion illustrates, the limitations in VRAM and power remain crucial factors in how mobile GPUs compare across different generations.
Source:
Link
Leave a Reply